We Could Be, But Should We?

We Could Be, But Should We? is the third episode of the first season of ClevanOTP's new fanfiction series, Rebel.

Plot
Suddenly, a love hexagon forms out of lust, romance, tension, jealousy and rivalry after Rebel and Toby start to form a close friendship with each other that ends up being love. However, Richie tries to get involved to get a piece out of Rebel, while Ronnie suddenly falls out of love with Toby to woo Siobhan, who's also torn when it comes to being attracted to Shiloh. Meanwhile, Jill starts to have sudden feelings for the club member Erik, who was claimed to have a bad reputation with girls.

Spoilers

 * Rebel will find himself becoming closer to Toby as their friendship evolves, however, besides Ronnie getting in the middle of it, Richie does.
 * Ronnie, instead, tries to woo Siobhan, because she believes that she may have had attractions to her before, but since she's into Shiloh, it seems as if those days are gone.
 * Someone will try to explain Richie and Stevie's bad reputation at school to Rebel.

Main Cast

 * Landon Liboiron as Matthew "Rebel" Steinfieldt.
 * Imogen Poots as Siobhan Mata.
 * Brittany Snow as Veronica "Ronnie" Chase.
 * Mila Kunis as Shiloh Haynes.
 * Nico Tortorella as Toby Harverson.
 * Daren Kagasoff as Richie Foster.
 * Hutch Dano as Stevie Hoff.
 * Luke Pasqualino as Gregorio De La Cruz.
 * Kat Dennings as Jill Steinfieldt.
 * Francia Raisa as Penelope "Nellie" Garcia-Ramirez.
 * Lauren London as Heather Garnett.

Recurring Cast

 * Daniel Samonas as Tyler Santos.
 * Nicholas Hoult as Erik Rydinger.
 * Victoria Rowell as Vincent Steinfieldt.
 * Peter Gallagher as Karen Steinfieldt.